| What
Treatments Are Available?
For decades, medications have been used to treat the symptoms of ADHD.
Three medications in the class of drugs known as stimulants seem to be
the most effective in both children and adults. These are methylphenidate
(Ritalin), dextroamphetamine (Dexedrine or Dextrostat), and pemoline
(Cylert). For many people, these medicines dramatically reduce their
hyperactivity and improve their ability to focus, work, and learn. The
medications may also improve physical coordination, such as handwriting
and ability in sports. Recent research by NIMH suggests that these medicines
may also help children with an accompanying conduct disorder to control
their impulsive, destructive behaviors.
Ritalin helped Henry focus on and complete tasks for the first time.
Dexedrine helped Mark to sit quietly, focus his attention, and participate
in class so he could learn. He also became less impulsive and aggressive.
Along with these changes in his behavior, Mark began to make and keep
friends.
Unfortunately, when people see such immediate improvement, they often
think medication is all that's needed. But these medicines don't cure
the disorder, they only temporarily control the symptoms. Although the
drugs help people pay better attention and complete their work, they
can't increase knowledge or improve academic skills. The drugs alone
can't help people feel better about themselves or cope with problems.
These require other kinds of treatment and support.
For lasting improvement, numerous clinicians recommend that medications
should be used along with treatments that aid in these other areas. There
are no quick cures. Many experts believe that the most significant, long-lasting
gains appear when medication is combined with behavioral therapy, emotional
counseling, and practical support. Some studies suggest that the combination
of medicine and therapy may be more effective than drugs alone. NIMH
is conducting a large study to check this.
Use of Stimulant Drugs
Stimulant drugs, such as Ritalin, Cylert, and Dexedrine, when used with
medical supervision, are usually considered quite safe. Although they
can be addictive to teenagers and adults if misused, these medications
are not addictive in children. They seldom make children "high" or
jittery. Nor do they sedate the child. Rather, the stimulants help children
control their hyperactivity, inattention, and other behaviors.
Different doctors use the medications in slightly different ways. Cylert
is available in one form, which naturally lasts 5 to 10 hours. Ritalin
and Dexedrine come in short-term tablets that last about 3 hours, as
well as longer-term preparations that last through the school day. The
short-term dose is often more practical for children who need medication
only during the school day or for special situations, like attending
church or a prom, or studying for an important exam. The sustained-release
dosage frees the child from the inconvenience or embarrassment of going
to the office or school nurse every day for a pill. The doctor can help
decide which preparation to use, and whether a child needs to take the
medicine during school hours only or in the evenings and on weekends,
too.
Nine out of 10 children improve on one of the three stimulant drugs.
So if one doesn't help, the others should be tried. Usually a medication
should be tried for a week to see if it helps. If necessary, however,
the doctor will also try adjusting the dosage before switching to a different
drug.
Other types of medication may be used if stimulants don't work or if
the ADHD occurs with another disorder. Antidepressants and other medications
may be used to help control accompanying depression or anxiety. In some
cases, antihistamines may be tried. Clonidine, a drug normally used to
treat hypertension, may be helpful in people with both ADHD and Tourette's
syndrome. Although stimulants tend to be more effective, clonidine may
be tried when stimulants don't work or can't be used. Clonidine can be
administered either by pill or by skin patch and has different side effects
than stimulants. The doctor works closely with each patient to find the
most appropriate medication.
Sometimes, a child's ADHD symptoms seem to worsen, leading parents to
wonder why. They can be assured that a drug that helps rarely stops working.
However, they should work with the doctor to check that the child is
getting the right dosage. Parents should also make sure that the child
is actually getting the prescribed daily dosage at home or at school--it's
easy to forget. They also need to know that new or exaggerated behaviors
may also crop up when a child is under stress. The challenges that all
children face, like changing schools or entering puberty, may be even
more stressful for a child with ADHD.
Some doctors recommend that children be taken off a medication now and
then to see if the child still needs it. They recommend temporarily stopping
the drug during school breaks and summer vacations, when focused attention
and calm behavior are usually not as crucial. These "drug holidays" work
well if the child can still participate at camp or other activities without
medication.
Children on medications should have regular checkups. Parents should
also talk regularly with the child's teachers and doctor about how the
child is doing. This is especially important when a medication is first
started, re-started, or when the dosage is changed.
The Medication Debate
As useful as these drugs are, Ritalin and the other stimulants have
sparked a great deal of controversy. Most doctors feel the potential
side effects should be carefully weighed against the benefits before
prescribing the drugs. While on these medications, some children may
lose weight, have less appetite, and temporarily grow more slowly. Others
may have problems falling asleep. Some doctors believe that stimulants
may also make the symptoms of Tourette's syndrome worse, although recent
research suggests this may not be true. Other doctors say if they carefully
watch the child's height, weight, and overall development, the benefits
of medication far outweigh the potential side effects. Side effects that
do occur can often be handled by reducing the dosage.
It's natural for parents to be concerned about whether taking a medicine
is in their child's best interests. Parents need to be clear about the
benefits and potential risks of using these drugs. The child's pediatrician
or psychiatrist can provide advice and answer questions.
Another debate is whether Ritalin and other stimulant drugs are prescribed
unnecessarily for too many children. Remember that many things, including
anxiety, depression, allergies, seizures, or problems with the home or
school environment can make children seem overactive, impulsive, or inattentive.
Critics argue that many children who do not have a true attention disorder
are medicated as a way to control their disruptive behaviors.
Medication and Self-Esteem
When a child's schoolwork and behavior improve soon after starting medication,
the child, parents, and teachers tend to applaud the drug for causing
the sudden change. But these changes are actually the child's own strengths
and natural abilities coming out from behind a cloud. Giving credit to
the medication can make the child feel incompetent. The medication only
makes these changes possible. The child must supply the effort and ability.
To help children feel good about themselves, parents and teachers need
to praise the child, not the drug.
It's also important to help children and teenagers feel comfortable
about a medication they must take every day. They may feel that because
they take medicine they are different from their classmates or that there's
something seriously wrong with them. CH.A.D.D. (which stands for Children
and Adults with Attention Deficit Disorders), a leading organization
for people with attention disorders, suggests several ways that parents
and teachers can help children view the medication in a positive way:
- Compare the pills to eyeglasses, braces, and allergy medications
used by other children in their class. Explain that their medicine
is simply a tool to help them focus and pay attention.
- Point out that they're lucky their problem can be helped. Encourage
them to identify ways the medicine makes it easier to do things that
are important to them, like make friends, succeed at school, and play.
Myths About Stimulant Medication
-
Myth:
Stimulants can lead to drug addiction later in life.
-
Fact:
Stimulants help many children focus and be more successful at school,
home, and play. Avoiding negative experiences now may actually help
prevent addictions and other emotional problems later.
-
Myth:
Responding well to a stimulant drug proves a person has ADHD.
-
Fact:
Stimulants allow many people to focus and pay better attention, whether
or not they have ADHD. The improvement is just more noticeable in people
with ADHD.
-
Myth:
Medication should be stopped when the child reaches adolescence.
-
Fact:
Not so! About 80 percent of those who needed medication as children
still need it as teenagers. Fifty percent need medication as adults.
Treatments To Help People With ADHD and Their Families Learn To Cope
Life can be hard for children with ADHD. They're the ones who are so
often in trouble at school, can't finish a game, and lose friends. They
may spend agonizing hours each night struggling to keep their mind on
their homework, then forget to bring it to school.
It's not easy coping with these frustrations day after day. Some children
release their frustration by acting contrary, starting fights, or destroying
property. Some turn the frustration into body ailments, like the child
who gets a stomachache each day before school. Others hold their needs
and fears inside, so that no one sees how badly they feel.
It's also difficult having a sister, brother, or classmate who gets
angry, grabs your toys, and loses your things. Children who live with
or share a classroom with a child who has ADHD get frustrated, too. They
may feel neglected as their parents or teachers try to cope with the
hyperactive child. They may resent their brother or sister never finishing
chores, or being pushed around by a classmate. They want to love their
sibling and get along with their classmate, but sometimes it's so hard!
It's especially hard being the parent of a child who is full of uncontrolled
activity, leaves messes, throws tantrums, and doesn't listen or follow
instructions. Parents often feel powerless and at a loss. The usual methods
of discipline, like reasoning and scolding, don't work with this child,
because the child doesn't really choose to act in these ways. It's just
that their self-control comes and goes. Out of sheer frustration, parents
sometimes find themselves spanking, ridiculing, or screaming at the child,
even though they know it's not appropriate. Their response leaves everyone
more upset than before. Then they blame themselves for not being better
parents. Once children are diagnosed and receiving treatment, some of
the emotional upset within the family may fade.
Medication can help to control some of the behavior problems that may
have lead to family turmoil. But more often, there are other aspects
of the problem that medication can't touch. Even though ADHD primarily
affects a person's behavior, having the disorder has broad emotional
repercussions. For some children, being scolded is the only attention
they ever get. They have few experiences that build their sense of worth
and competence. If they're hyperactive, they're often told they're bad
and punished for being disruptive. If they are too disorganized and unfocused
to complete tasks, others may call them lazy. If they impulsively grab
toys, butt in, or shove classmates, they may lose friends. And if they
have a related conduct disorder, they may get in trouble at school or
with the law. Facing the daily frustrations that can come with having
ADHD can make people fear that they are strange, abnormal, or stupid.
Often, the cycle of frustration, blame, and anger has gone on so long
that it will take some time to undo. Both parents and their children
may need special help to develop techniques for managing the patterns
of behavior. In such cases, mental health professionals can counsel the
child and the family, helping them to develop new skills, attitudes,
and ways of relating to each other. In individual counseling, the therapist
helps children or adults with ADHD learn to feel better about themselves.
They learn to recognize that having a disability does not reflect who
they are as a person. The therapist can also help people with ADHD identify
and build on their strengths, cope with daily problems, and control their
attention and aggression. In group counseling, people learn that they
are not alone in their frustration and that others want to help. Sometimes
only the individual with ADHD needs counseling support. But in many cases,
because the problem affects the family as well as the person with ADHD,
the entire family may need help. The therapist assists the family in
finding better ways to handle the disruptive behaviors and promote change.
If the child is young, most of the therapist's work is with the parents,
teaching them techniques for coping with and improving their child's
behavior.
Several intervention approaches are available and different therapists
tend to prefer one approach or another. Knowing something about the various
types of interventions makes it easier for families to choose a therapist
that is right for their needs.
Psychotherapy works to help people with ADHD
to like and accept themselves despite their disorder. In psychotherapy,
patients talk with the therapist about upsetting thoughts and feelings,
explore self-defeating patterns of behavior, and learn alternative ways
to handle their emotions. As they talk, the therapist tries to help them
understand how they can change. However, people dealing with ADHD usually
want to gain control of their symptomatic behaviors more directly. If
so, more direct kinds of intervention are needed.
Cognitive-behavioral therapy helps people
work on immediate issues. Rather than helping people understand their
feelings and actions, it supports them directly in changing their behavior.
The support might be practical assistance, like helping Henry learn to
think through tasks and organize his work. Or the support might be to
encourage new behaviors by giving praise or rewards each time the person
acts in the desired way. A cognitive-behavioral therapist might use such
techniques to help a belligerent child like Mark learn to control his
fighting, or an impulsive teenager like Lisa to think before she speaks.
Social skills training can also help children
learn new behaviors. In social skills training, the therapist discusses
and models appropriate behaviors like waiting for a turn, sharing toys,
asking for help, or responding to teasing, then gives children a chance
to practice. For example, a child might learn to "read" other people's
facial expression and tone of voice, in order to respond more appropriately.
Social skills training helped Lisa learn to join in group activities,
make appropriate comments, and ask for help. A child like Mark might
learn to see how his behavior affects others and develop new ways to
respond when angry or pushed.
Support groups connect people who have common
concerns. Many adults with ADHD and parents of children with ADHD find
it useful to join a local or national support group. Many groups deal
with issues of children's disorders, and even ADHD specifically. The
national associations listed at the back of this booklet can explain
how to contact a local chapter. Members of support groups share frustrations
and successes, referrals to qualified specialists, and information about
what works, as well as their hopes for themselves and their children.
There is strength in numbers--and sharing experiences with others who
have similar problems helps people know that they aren't alone.
Parenting skills training, offered by therapists
or in special classes, gives parents tools and techniques for managing
their child's behavior. One such technique is the use of "time out" when
the child becomes too unruly or out of control. During time outs, the
child is removed from the agitating situation and sits alone quietly
for a short time to calm down. Parents may also be taught to give the
child "quality time" each day, in which they share a pleasurable or relaxed
activity. During this time together, the parent looks for opportunities
to notice and point out what the child does well, and praise his or her
strengths and abilities.
An effective way to modify a child's behavior is through a system of
rewards and penalties. The parents (or teacher) identify a few desirable
behaviors that they want to encourage in the child--such as asking for
a toy instead of grabbing it, or completing a simple task. The child
is told exactly what is expected in order to earn the reward. The child
receives the reward when he performs the desired behavior and a mild
penalty when he doesn't. A reward can be small, perhaps a token that
can be exchanged for special privileges, but it should be something the
child wants and is eager to earn. The penalty might be removal of a token
or a brief "time out." The goal, over time, is to help children learn
to control their own behavior and to choose the more desired behavior.
The technique works well with all children, although children with ADHD
may need more frequent rewards.
In addition, parents may learn to structure situations in ways that
will allow their child to succeed. This may include allowing only one
or two playmates at a time, so that their child doesn't get overstimulated.
Or if their child has trouble completing tasks, they may learn to help
the child divide a large task into small steps, then praise the child
as each step is completed.
Parents may also learn to use stress management methods, such as meditation,
relaxation techniques, and exercise to increase their own tolerance for
frustration, so that they can respond more calmly to their child's behavior.
Controversial Treatments
Understandably, parents who are eager to help their children want to
explore every possible option. Many newly touted treatments sound reasonable.
Many even come with glowing reports. A few are pure quackery. Some are
even developed by reputable doctors or specialists--but when tested scientifically,
cannot be proven to help.
Here are a few types of treatment that have not been scientifically
shown to be effective in treating the majority of children or adults
with ADHD:
- biofeedback
- restricted diets
- allergy treatments
- medicines to correct problems in the inner ear
- megavitamins
- chiropractic adjustment and bone re-alignment
- treatment for yeast infection
- eye training
- special colored glasses
A few success stories can't substitute for scientific evidence. Until
sound, scientific testing shows a treatment to be effective, families
risk spending time, money, and hope on fads and false promises.
|